Midway down page two of a City of Excelsior request for proposals, released October 27, 2025, the word "Bathhouse" comes with a two-word note: "currently condemned." A few lines below that, the same document asks designers how the small beach should be used "if 'beach closure' risk cannot be mitigated."
The plan the Excelsior City Council approved on August 17 is publicly described as a short list of new things: a playground, a beach house, courts and docks. The planning document behind it starts from a building the city can't use and a beach it can't count on.
What the Council Approved
Community for The Commons is the nonprofit that raises money for the park. It reports that the Council approved the Commons Mini Master Plan on August 17, 2026, and it calls the plan "the next chapter for our favorite gathering place." According to the group, the next phase covers four pieces:
- A playground
- A beach house
- Pickleball and tennis courts
- Beach and adventure docks
The city's RFP describes the plan as covering "a subsection of Commons Park." That subsection holds the playground, both beaches, the tennis courts, the bathhouse, the picnic area and the spaces around them. The RFP also says the work should follow the design criteria and materials of the original 2017 Commons Master Plan.
The Beach House Starts From a Building That Can't Be Used
Of the four pieces, the beach house is the one the city had the least choice about. Because the existing bathhouse is condemned, the question was what would replace it, not whether to replace it.
The design brief for the replacement is practical. The city asked for bathrooms large enough to work as dressing rooms for the beach, covered seating, outdoor showers and a foot-washing station. It also asked that the building's style, design and materials stay "relatively consistent" with the Plaza building, and floated firepits like the ones at The Commons Plaza.
If you've sat by the fire at the Plaza, you've already seen the look the city is aiming for. The new building is meant to match what is already there.
The Small Beach Is the Open Question
The Commons has two beaches, and the RFP uses the names people already call them. The Large Beach is listed "aka Adult Beach" and includes the ground to the right of it as you face the lake. The Small Beach is listed "aka Kids Beach."
For the Kids Beach, the city gave designers three things to think about:
- How it could be integrated with the playground
- How a water feature in the playground might work with it
- How the beach should be used if the risk of closures can't be reduced
The third item matters most. Water quality appears again elsewhere in the document. The parking area is listed for "longer term" work, and its design notes name "Storm Water/E.coli contamination" next to the fire lane and safety features that keep vehicles away from the playground.
Because of that list, the Kids Beach can't be planned on its own. Any answer for the small beach also involves the playground beside it, and the playground is the piece the city put first.
Why the Playground Goes First
The city wrote down its priority order plainly. The RFP calls the playground renovation "the highest priority project within the scope of this plan."
The document sets out two phases of work. Phase 1 is design. Phase 2 covers bid documents, construction specifications and construction oversight, and it would normally begin only after the full mini master plan is done. The playground is the stated exception. The city kept the option to move it into Phase 2 early if it could be done "in conjunction with the mini master plan design efforts."
The playground RFI attached to the proposal describes three play zones. The main area is for ages 2 to 5 and 6 to 12. A beachfront extension is for ages 6 to 12. An upper agility area is for ages 12 and up. Its stated goals are inclusive access, shade and seating, and appeal in every season. Like everything else in the RFP, these are criteria the city handed to designers. They are not confirmed features of the approved plan.
How Earlier Commons Projects Moved
The Commons has rebuilt itself in steps before, and the earlier steps moved quickly. Community for The Commons lists the record:
| Project | Committee formed | Approved and completed | Design and construction |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Pavilion | 2020 | 2021 | VJAA Architects, Damon Farber, Gardner Builders |
| The Plaza | 2021 | 2022 | VJAA Architects, Damon Farber, Gardner Builders |
| Ballfield | Not listed | Started 2025, completed 2026 | HKGI |
The Pavilion and the Plaza each went from a newly formed committee to a finished project in about a year. The ballfield renovation brought new dugouts, drain tile and sod, rain gardens and new lighting, and it restored the historic WPA seating area. It took longer. A city notice said construction would begin August 4, 2025 and run through that fall, with trail and sidewalk closures along the way. Community for The Commons now lists that project as completed in 2026.
The new plan covers more pieces than any of those projects, and each of them was built as a single project with its own design team.
The Calendar the City Drew
The RFP included the city's own estimated timeline. Here it is next to the public steps that followed:
| City's estimate in the October 2025 RFP | What happened publicly |
|---|---|
| Q1 2026: High-level plan concepts, first playground designs | April 16, 2026: City pop-up event to review and comment on park and playground concepts |
| Q2 2026: Approval of playground project, detailed plan concepts | June 17, 2026: Mini master plan pop-up at Concerts in The Commons, 5 to 8:30 p.m. |
| Q3 2026: Playground installation, final plan approval | July 14, 2026: Parks and Recreation Commission update on the plan and playground design |
| Council approval no later than September 30, 2026 | August 17, 2026: Council approval, per Community for The Commons |
The approval came about six weeks before the city's own deadline. The design part of the schedule held. The construction part is still pending. The nonprofit's page says only, "Soon we begin the next phase," and no cost figures or construction dates have been published alongside the approval. The public meetings were listed on the city calendar and the Parks and Recreation Commission agenda, and those are the places to watch for the next update.
What the City Asked for Beyond the Big Four
The playground, beach house, courts and docks are the headline items. The RFP's longer list shows how the city wants the park to work for people who live near it and use it all year. Designers were asked to consider:
- Courts: tennis, pickleball and basketball, ADA access, and a landscaped sound barrier facing the street and nearby homes
- The picnic lawn: the open space between the courts and the playground, now used for picnics and grills, where the current rental structure sits
- On the water: a kayak launch, a kayak rental shack and storage, a fishing pier, and storage for residents' paddleboards and kayaks
- The knoll: protecting the area behind left and center field, a possible walkway or boardwalk around it, and a plan to "remove or reimagine" the swing area
- Seating: creative, shaded, with views, and planned with grandparents in mind
- Art: rotating pieces rather than permanent ones, described as "regional park worthy"
The last goal on the list is the one that matters this month. The city asked designers for a "winter strategy" to get more use out of The Commons in the colder months, including a possible ice-skating area. This season, the nearest winter event is downtown. Christmas in Excelsior, presented by the Excelsior Lions Club, runs November 27 and 28 from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m., with photos with Santa at Excelsior Masonic Lodge #113, 249 Water Street.
If you live near The Commons, the work there may affect your own plans in the next year or two, whether that means traffic and noise on your street or the timing of a sale. Ryan Johnson Group follows park projects like this one closely and is glad to talk it through with you, even if you aren't planning a move.